I have a permanent chalkboard with a fancy frame that my husband made over my kitchen window out of reclaimed wood and recycled bullet brass. Details can be found here.
I have used cardboard. Over time, cardboard isn't the best choice but it was a low investment. (Like a really low investment since it was recycled cardboard) This chalkboard was shaped like a conversation bubble. Kids really like it.
link to the whole series
check out Write31Days